5

As a member of Gaming Stack Exchange, I've noticed that while some gaming-related questions receive a lot of attention, others tend to go into obscurity—even if they're well-written and interesting. I'm curious:

  1. What steps can be taken to ensure questions stand out and encourage active discussion?
  2. Are there techniques for improving the quality of answers and fostering long-term engagement with such posts?

I’ve tried observing patterns in popular questions and experimenting with phrasing and tags, but I haven’t found a consistent formula for success.

6
  • 7
    Posts about AAA titles and popular multiplayer games (looking at you, Minecraft) will get lots of answers and attention, guaranteed. Less popular games' questions, especially when nobody has first hand experience, may go unanswered; and if they do get answered it'll be by compiling something out of third party sources to try and figure something out in a vacuum, which takes a lot more effort and you can't even necessarily verify what you're claiming is the solution because you don't play the game. I'm not sure you can fix the experience gap - there's too many games out there. Commented Apr 13 at 12:58
  • Yeah! I'm a minecrafter! that could be useful.. Commented Apr 14 at 0:43
  • 4
    @ZOMBIE_JERKY I fear you are simply seeing the effect of the Low Hanging Fruit problem. Are you familiar with the Catch-22 paradox? The network has a similar issue. Either you post easily googleable questions and get answers or you are one of those users that only post here after researching the topic online and finding no answer... in which case 90% of the time no one else will too.... [cont]
    – SPArcheon
    Commented Apr 14 at 9:32
  • 3
    [cont] ... and that is assuming someone want to work on you hard-to-answer question in the first place when there is a ripe "what button do I press to open the inventory" question nearby posted by the usual question flooder users
    – SPArcheon
    Commented Apr 14 at 9:33
  • 4
    "encourage active discussion" if any, SE is basically a Q&A site, and extended discussion (compared with Reddit) is mainly discouraged.
    – antimo
    Commented Apr 14 at 10:13
  • Related: Is anyone on the site still playing new AAA games? Commented Apr 17 at 8:11

1 Answer 1

4

What steps can be taken to ensure questions stand out and encourage active discussion?

There's not much you can do to ensure questions stand out, besides asking questions about popular games. The more popular something is, the more attention people will pay to it. Unfortunately, that means questions about obscure topics will very quickly fade away, probably with just views, no votes or answers. Of course, if a question is well written, that can help, but someone won't know that before clicking, and will be more likely to click on the question with a popular tag than a question about something few people know about.

You could vote, of course, but the vast majority of questions don't get much votes, and the ones that do have a much lower vote count than view count. Unfortunately, this isn't really something we can fix, unless we provide some incentive for voting (which is its own topic entirely).

There's not really any kind of community engagement besides asking and answering questions. Comments aren't meant for conversation, they're meant to ask for clarification on OP's part.

And this isn't necessarily a bad thing. SE sites aren't meant to provoke conversations. They exist so that users can get helpful, high-quality answers to helpful, high-quality questions. That's what sets us apart. If you want to have a conversation with someone, you'd be better off going to Reddit or similar. Harsh, maybe, but true.

Are there techniques for improving the quality of answers and fostering long-term engagement with such posts?

Anyone can edit questions and answers (though if you don't have enough reputation, your edit will be reviewed). This keeps posts high quality, and also means that people don't have to keep coming back to keep their posts looking nice. If posts aren't helpful, they can be flagged or closed, in which case more high-rep users will come along. And again, there's not meant to be engagement besides voting and posting answers/questions.


If you do want to interact with the community, however, we have places for that. We have The Bridge (our main chatroom), a Steam Commmunity (dead, unfortunately), and a Discord (very slightly less dead).

2
  • I don't have a link to the Discord, could one of the owners add one?
    – Otakuwu
    Commented Apr 14 at 19:16
  • 1
    strongly agree with the second half. we're not instagram, "engagement" isn't a metric that somehow is inherently desirable. if a question generates engagement, then it's probably because it's interesting to look at (or it's out of context title of the week in HNQ ;), but that just means if what we really want is more engagement then more interesting questions should be asked and that's simply not what a q&a site is about. Commented Apr 25 at 12:20

You must log in to answer this question.

Start asking to get answers

Find the answer to your question by asking.

Ask question

Explore related questions

See similar questions with these tags.